This mascara really does look amazing and I would be extremely surprised if anyone, even oily lid people, get panda eyes from this… until you try to wash it off. The lower rating is because I’ve washed my face three times since applying inc with an oil cleanser and it still won’t really come off. I’ve tried soaking my lashes in warm water to see if it’d come off like a tubing mascara, still not really coming off. And since first trying to wash it off, I am getting panda eyes but before that, it looked PERFECT even after a long night of dancing. I’m gonna keep this mascara for very special occasions but I fear regular use will result in me losing a lot of lashes trying to wash it off.

BEST waterproof mascara I have ever used! I bought for our trip to Raro because I knew I’d be swimming a lot. No joke, after swimming all day, showering and even doing my full face cleansing routine at night (which includes oil cleaner) this mascara still wouldn’t budge.
It doesn’t smudge or crumble during the day or after being wet.
I found the best/ easiest way for me to take it off was rubbing tiny blob of Argan hair oil on my lashes to soften it then it just wipes away.

I also pair it with the Dr Mascara fixer perfect lash which helps keep the curl in my lashes. Perfection every time
This is the only mascara I’ll be using from now on!

I've been looking for a mascara like this forever! It doesn't clump up and make spidery lashes. I wore this all day on both upper and lower lashes and had zero smudging under my eye which I had issues with a previous mascara I used so I'm super happy to have found this one. It's perfect if you want a "natural" looking, non clumpy mascara. For sure my new go-to mascara, I will repurchase!

Literally best Asian mascara ever! Doesn't clump too much and lengthens, volumizes as well! Recommend🫡

Best mascara ive ever had!